
A Lithuanian national, known as AB, has seen his bid to prevent extradition to face bribery charges rejected by the High Court of Justiciary, which dismissed concerns regarding prison conditions, threats from an organized crime group, health issues, and the impact on his family life.
Extradition ruling comes after eight-year stay in the UK
On 26 March 2026, a sheriff in Edinburgh ordered AB’s extradition, acting on a European Arrest Warrant issued in June 2016. AB had initially appeared in court in Lithuania on bribery charges, entering a not guilty plea, and his case was subsequently adjourned for four months. He was then released under certain conditions, including a requirement to report to the authorities and a prohibition on leaving the country.
However, AB traveled to the UK for his father’s funeral and chose not to return to Lithuania. He has since lived in Scotland for approximately eight or nine years, acquiring settled status, while his five children remained in Lithuania, although one of his sons had previously resided with him in Glasgow. AB also has relatives in Scotland and other parts of the UK.
Three main grounds for opposing extradition
AB opposed extradition before the sheriff on three main grounds: firstly, that it would interfere disproportionately with his right to a private and family life under Article 8; secondly, that detention in Lithuania would expose him to treatment that contravenes Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, due to prison conditions and threats from a criminal gang; and thirdly, that extradition was barred due to the passage of time, as per section 14 of the Extradition Act 2003.
During the hearing, AB claimed to have borrowed money from a criminal gang in Lithuania, stating that the debt had grown from £5,000 to £70,000. His nephew testified that he had received threatening calls and messages and had made payments towards the debt. An expert on Lithuanian prison conditions, George Tugushi, raised concerns about inadequate healthcare, poor facilities, and inter-prisoner violence linked to informal hierarchies. However, Tugushi’s last visit to a Lithuanian prison was in 2018, and he could not comment specifically on the risks AB might face.
The sheriff did not find AB to be a credible witness, noting inconsistencies between his testimony and that of his nephew. Nevertheless, the sheriff accepted that the threat from the gang was genuine. The sheriff concluded that AB had limited close family ties in Scotland and that extradition would cause minimal interference with his private or family life, especially when weighed against the public interest in honoring extradition obligations. The sheriff also determined that AB was a fugitive and that, although the passage of time was substantial, there was no credible evidence to suggest that extradition would be unjust or oppressive.
Regarding Article 3, the sheriff acknowledged that violence existed within the Lithuanian prison system but was not convinced that AB faced a real risk of prohibited ill-treatment. The sheriff treated Tugushi’s evidence with caution, given its lack of specificity to AB’s case and its age. The sheriff relied on assurances from the Lithuanian prison service regarding accommodation, vulnerability assessment, protection, and conditions for prisoners placed in isolation for their safety.
The judges reviewed supplementary guarantees from Lithuanian officials, confirming that AB would first be held at Kaunas prison and that any future placement decisions would factor in safety risks, public security concerns, health requirements, medical needs, and any evidence suggesting he should avoid certain inmates.
Lord Matthews, joined by Lady Wise and Lady Carmichael, ruled that the sheriff’s assessment of gang-related threats and prison safety concerns was justified.
Concerns over Lithuanian prison conditions
The court also reviewed a 2024 European Committee for the Prevention of Torture report, which highlighted progress—such as lower prison populations and better addiction programs—while still warning about persistent issues like informal inmate power structures, criminal organizations, and frequent violence among detainees. Still, the court determined that the proposed safeguards adequately addressed AB’s specific risks.
Seven grounds raised in the appeal
AB’s appeal raised seven concerns, including violations of Articles 2, 3, 6, and 8, his health status, the delay in extradition proceedings, interpreter difficulties, and claims of inadequate prior legal advice.
The court weighed additional commitments from Lithuanian authorities, which confirmed AB’s initial detention at Kaunas prison and promised that any future custody decisions would evaluate risks, public safety, medical needs, and potential conflicts with other inmates.
The court concluded that none of the seven grounds had merit and refused leave to appeal, leaving the sheriff‘s extradition order in place.