US Agencies Urged to Share Rulemaking Expertise

by Mika Ogata • 10 hours ago

Share It:

US Agencies Urged to Share Rulemaking Expertise - rulemaking expertise
A study analyzed 60 internal rulemaking guides, the preambles of 204 major proposed regulations, and interviews with 21 agency rule writers.

The Administrative Conference of the United States (ACUS) recommends that agencies engage in early dialogue and flexible communication practices to improve interagency input in rulemaking. This approach enables agencies to share expertise and experience, providing feedback on drafts of proposed rules and coordinating related regulatory actions.

Government agencies improve their regulations when they collaborate effectively, tapping into shared expertise and better information. Such coordination helps them craft smarter policies while reducing unnecessary duplication and bureaucratic hurdles that often arise from overlapping rules.

Improving Interagency Coordination

A study analyzed 60 internal rulemaking guides, the preambles of 204 major proposed regulations, and interviews with 21 agency rule writers. The analysis uncovered five key takeaways, one being that most agencies regularly seek input from counterparts while shaping new rules.

The depth of collaboration varies based on how closely agencies’ goals align and how much a proposed rule could disrupt another agency’s operations. Drafting teams place the highest value on peer feedback before releasing a draft or submitting it to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs.

Agencies primarily turn to their professional networks—built over years of government service—to gather input on rule drafts. These discussions are usually spontaneous, with officials from one agency meeting or exchanging notes with peers at another to assess a proposed rule’s potential.

ACUS Recommendation 2026-5

Based on the research, the Administrative Conference of the United States (ACUS) approved Recommendation 2026-5, titled Interagency Communication in Rulemaking. This guidance outlines best practices for when agencies should actively seek peer input and how they should incorporate that feedback.

Read Also: High Court rejects Lithuanian man’s appeal over extradition

The recommendation urges agencies to reach out to counterparts early in the process, especially when required by law or when another agency’s regulations could be heavily impacted. It also encourages informal discussions among officials throughout the rulemaking phase.

Noting the importance of current agency practices, the recommendation discusses circumstances where informal communication is particularly valuable between agencies, such as when discussing upcoming regulatory activities or coordinating regulatory agendas. The recommendation also recognizes that in certain circumstances, agencies should consider standardizing communications processes.

As agencies begin to implement Recommendation 2026-5, they will be able to cultivate critical dialogue between agencies in rulemaking, promoting accuracy, efficiency, and transparency. The Administrative Conference of the United States provides agencies with the tools necessary to improve interagency coordination and create better rules.

The report advises agencies to carefully review all meaningful feedback from other departments on draft and proposed rules, weighing legal and practical considerations before deciding whether to include those exchanges in public records or judicial files. It also stresses the need for internal policies outlining how, when, and why agencies should engage in interagency discussions, referencing the 21 rule writers interviewed.

Christopher Carrigan, an associate professor at the George Washington University Trachtenberg School of Public Policy and Public Administration, co-directed the GW Regulatory Studies Center.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *