ACUS issues guidance for drafting regulatory preambles

by Yui Yoshida • 2 days ago

Share It:

ACUS issues guidance for drafting regulatory preambles - regulatory preambles
Post Loper Bright, agencies should provide what they believe to be the best interpretation of a statute they administer, even when the statute is ambiguous.

The Administrative Conference of the United States (ACUS) has adopted a recommendation, “Best Practices for Drafting Regulatory Preambles in Light of Judicial Review,” to guide agency rule drafters in explaining their statutory interpretations and regulatory choices. This recommendation is particularly relevant given the shifting judicial review environment, with recent cases such as Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo ending Chevron deference and the U.S. Supreme Court developing the major questions doctrine.

The preamble attached to agencies’ proposed and final rules explains the agency’s legal authority, policy choices, and, when attached to a final rule, typically provides the agency’s response to significant public comments. It provides valuable guidance to the regulated community and the public, and courts often rely on it when judging the validity of agency policymaking.

Evolution of Judicial Review

Administrative law has been changing rapidly, with the end of Chevron deference-under which courts were required to defer to reasonable agency interpretations of ambiguous statutes-and the development of the major questions doctrine. Recent cases have also shaped how agencies approach formulating regulatory policy, including arbitrary-and-capricious review of agency policy decisions. ACUS commissioned a report on drafting regulatory preambles in order to help agency rule drafters handle recent developments in how courts review agency rules.

The report, which was written by one of us, Deacon, and overseen for ACUS by the other, Nowacki, draws on a review of case law, academic commentary, recent preambles, as well as interviews with 19 current and former agency officials with experience within the new judicial review environment. It emphasizes the need for agencies to carefully attend to statutory text, consequences of proposed or final rules, and possible alternative policy options.

Post Loper Bright, agencies should provide what they believe to be the best interpretation of a statute they administer, even when the statute is ambiguous. The report counsels that agencies consider remaining eclectic in their approach to assessing statutory interpretation questions, taking into account factors such as the statutory text, the broader statutory scheme, and workability.

Related Post: Court Clarifies Document Use in Simple Procedure Cases

Best Practices for Drafting Regulatory Preambles

ACUS Recommendation 2026-6 prescribes best practices for agencies to use when drafting preambles, focusing on two key aspects of the agency’s explanation: the agency’s interpretation of relevant statutes and the reasonableness of the rule being promulgated. The recommendation encourages agencies to explain why the rule is consistent with the best interpretation of the relevant statute and to identify the source of express or implied delegated discretionary authority.

The recommendation also suggests that agencies identify in preambles the reasoning for proposing or adopting the rule, including explaining the criteria considered in developing the rule and how the rule advances statutory objectives. Agencies should address significant comments received and explain whether they considered significant alternatives, and if the rule represents a change in policy, explain why the new policy is justified.

The report discusses a number of other matters, including how agencies should articulate their view on whether a statute is best read to delegate the agency discretionary authority and how agencies should approach responding to significant comments. ACUS Recommendation 2026-6 builds on earlier recommendations, including best practices for the use of plain language and providing cost-benefit analyses.

In terms of the major questions doctrine, the report emphasizes the importance of agencies carefully considering whether their rules raise major questions concerns and explaining their reasoning in the preamble. This can help agencies to ensure that their rules are consistent with the best interpretation of the relevant statute and to provide a clear explanation of their regulatory choices.

Specific Considerations for Agencies

Agencies must clearly state if they believe they possess such power. The preamble should explain the source of this authority, whether it is express or implied. This distinction is critical when courts evaluate the scope of agency power under the new judicial review environment.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *